Meherrin Rejected

It was with both pleasure and horror that I read through the US government’s “Proposed Finding Against Acknowledgment” of the Meherrin Tribe’s application for federal recognition, dated January 16, 2014. It gave me pleasure because it provided a frank assessment of Meherrin tribal history from the contact era through the 18th century. And that’s just the thing — as far as the federal government is concerned, the Meherrin ceased to exist as a recognizable tribal entity in the mid-1760s.

Here comes the horror. Most of the petitioners descend from a woman named Sallie Matilda Smith Lewis (c.1844-1904). Fortunately for us, Mrs, Lewis left behind several portraits that show her to have fairly recognizable indigenous features, which is probably why the Meherrin Tribe is so happy to display her image on its website. But, unfortunately, looking like Sitting Bull and claiming Native American descent does not make one eligible for federal recognition in the eyes of the state these days.

What plays a greater role is that her father, Jacob Smith, and family members, were described as mulattoes on the US censuses. As the anthropologist Helen Rountree wrote in Pocahontas’ People, the word “mulatto” did not always mean “of African and European descent.” But Rountree is not cited by the federal government. Instead, it turns to Paul Heinegg’s genealogical work on free African Americans in Virginia and North Carolina in its proposed rejection. Heinegg informs them that most of the people are descended from couplings of African males and European females in Virginia, who removed to North Carolina. And if he says it, it must be true.

One of the worst things I have seen reading both the points of the Meherrin’s application, and the notes attributed to Heinegg and used in the proposed finding against the Meherrin, is the use of something called “surname analysis.” This is the idea that if two people have the same surname, they must be related in some way. In this way, very generic English names — Lewis, Smith — become designated “Free People of Color” {read Mulatto of African Descent} names.

It’s troublesome in my research, because my ancestors lived beside a lot of people with these names, who weren’t ever categorized as being mulattoes. For example, my Collins’ ancestors land in Nansemond County bordered property belonging to the Wiggins family. Someone using Heinegg’s resource might go and say, “Oh, well,  according to Paul Heinegg, Ann Wiggins, born 1682, had a child with a ‘negroe’ in Northumberland County, Virginia, in 1705 and then another in 1726, who was on a tax list in Bertie County in 1764 …”

Okay — according to this theory, Ann Wiggins had her first mulatto child in Northumberland County in 1705, when she was about 23 years old. That part I follow. What I don’t follow is how Sarah Wiggins, born in 1726 and resident in Bertie County in 1764 is the daughter of this woman. First of all, Ann Wiggins would have had to have been 44 years old in 1726 (and did she have any children during the previous two decades?). Second of all, Northumberland County is pretty far removed from Bertie. It sits on the Potomac River facing Maryland. Bertie County is over 180 miles to its south.

So, allow me to say that I am skeptical that Sarah Wiggins, born 1726, of Bertie County, was the daughter of Ann Wiggins, born 1682, of Northumberland County. Wiggins is a common English name. A few blocks away from my house in New York, there is a “Wiggins Lane.” Just as there are Archers listed as FPCs in Hertford County, North Carolina, records, from whom many Meherrin claim descent, there are Archers in Nansemond County, Virginia, who are NOT listed as FPCs. And here’s the US government basing their rejection of recognition of the Meherrin Indian Tribe on such slippery genealogy? Not to mention that most of the information available regards males. Who was Jacob Smith’s wife Ann? Nobody seems to know. And without an uninterrupted line of female descent and a DNA test, nobody will ever know.

Not that records could even help, because one family that did designate itself as Indian on the 1900 Census — that of John and Georgianna Collins — is also dismissed as not being Native American by the government.

None of the evidence in the record documented these claimed Indian identifications and, therefore, they do not demonstrate descent from a Meherrin tribe, or from one alternative tribe

So even if you say you are, and have an older record to prove it, you’re not. Okay, good to know.

I’ve been in contact with Heinegg for years and use his website frequently in my own to try and piece things together. He’s been very responsive and I find his work very valuable, though there is a reason he uses the word “probably” so often — because it is almost impossible to nail down many of these relationships. There are “mulatto” members of the Lang and Sweat families in Collins households in the 1850 and 1860 censuses, for example. Both of these names are associated with African Americans and Native Americans {as is the name Wiggins, by the way. Members of the Wiggins family signed several deeds on the Tuscarora’s behalf in the 1760s and 1770s (but were THEY real Indians?}. I have no idea what is the relation between these Langs and Sweats and the Collins, who are designated as white. I do know that in the 1850 census one is listed as white, and in the 1860 census, the same person is listed a mulatto. Which goes to show you how reliable the censuses are.

At the end of the the federal document there is an appendix which lists the 16 names of Meherrin identified in documents between 1650 and 1727. Somehow, the poor people of the Meherrin Indian Tribe in Winton, North Carolina, are supposed to find the records that link their “mulatto” families with Nick Major of 1711, or Captain Rogers of 1727. Good luck with that!

All this leaves me believing ever more in DNA testing. At least I was able to have my grandmother tested, and to see her Amerindian DNA. If she had any African ancestors, which is possible, they were far enough back that they did not have any impact on her DNA results. Most of the evidence I can find now links associated families with the Chowanoke remnants. Sarah Hinton, who married John Collins, in 1779, for instance, was probably the granddaughter of Tabitha Hoyter Freeman. Henry Eborn Sears, whose will was witnessed by William Collings, was the husband of Bathsheba Bennett. Bennett was also a Chowanoke surname, in fact, I cannot find any other Bennetts in that county at that time who were NOT Chowanoke.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Meherrin Rejected

  1. Troy says:

    Have you looked at these records? I believe Nick is living in Lunenburg VA after leaving Isle of Wight…and then Surry NC. I think I have a military record for him also. Cheers

    Section 13, Ludwell, Philip (1672-1727), Diary, 1710
    This section consists of one item, a diary, 18 July-10 October 1710, of Philip Ludwell II. The diary was kept at Williamsburg and in Surry and in Isle of Wight (now Southampton) counties, Virginia, and in Chowan (now Hertford) County, North Carolina, while Ludwell and Nathaniel Harrison were serving as Virginia commissioners to settle the boundary between Virginia and North Carolina. The diary includes correspondence, 1710, of Ludwell and Harrison with John Lawson and Edward Moseley.
    Entries concern John Allen, Harry Beverley, John Beverley, Richard Booth, Richard Braswell, Henry Briggs, William Browne, William Bush, Thomas Cotton, Mrs. [first name unknown] Early, James Farlee, Great Peter (Indian), William Hooker, Edward Hyde (while serving as governor of North Carolina), Edmund Jenings (while serving as president of the Virginia Council), Frederick Jones, William Maule, Charles Merritt, Henry Plumpton, Thomas Pollock, Edward Smithwick, John Smyth, Alexander Spotswood (while serving as governor of Virginia), Francis Toms, Robin Tucker (Indian), Richard Washington Henry Williams, William Williams, and Henry Wyche; the Meherrin, Nansemond, and Nottoway Indians; and the Council of Virginia.
    Section 14, Ludwell, Philip (1672-1727), Diary, 1710-1711
    This section consists of one item, a diary, 9 November 1710-7 August 1711, of Philip Ludwell II. The diary was kept at Green Spring, James City County, Hampton, and Williamsburg, and in the counties of Nansemond, Norfolk, Princess Anne, Southampton, and Surry, Virginia, and Gates and Hertford, North Carolina, while Ludwell and Nathaniel Harrison were serving as Virginia commissioners to settle the boundary between Virginia and North Carolina. The diary includes correspondence, 1710-1711, of Ludwell and Harrison with John Lawson and Edward Moseley.
    Entries concern John Arden, Edward Barnes, Harry Beverley, John Beverley, William Bonner, Richard Braswell, George Bullock, Stephen Burgess, John Clayton, Mrs. Sarah Clouse, [first name unknown] Cullock, John Dew, Mrs. [first name unknown] Early, John Fulcher, James Farlee, William Gamy, William Glover, Great Peter (Indian), William Hooker, Edward Hyde (while serving as governor), Francis Jones, Mrs. Francis Jones, Frederick Jones, Mrs. [first name unknown] Lassiter, Tanaquil LeFevre, Lawrence Mague, Nicholas Major (Indian), Edward Moseley (1661-1736), Francis Moss, Thomas Pollock, William Robertson, Edward Smithwick, Francis Spikes, [first name unknown] Walke, Thomas Walke, Henry [Walstein?], Mrs. Henry Walstein, Solomon White, William Williams, Thomas Williamson, and James Wilson.
    Section 15, Various Persons, Materials concerning the Boundary between Virginia and North Carolina, 1707
    This section consists of eight items, materials, 1707, of various persons concerning the boundary between Virginia and North Carolina. Items include a letter, 1707, of Francis Foster, William Glover, Edward Moseley, and Samuel Swann (while serving on the Council of North Carolina) to the Council of Virginia; a commission, 1707, of Arthur Allen, John Hardyman, Benjamin Harrison, Francis Mallory, John Poythress, and Joshua Wynne (signed by Edmund Jenings and bears seals of John Hardyman, Benjamin Harrison, Francis Mallory, and the colony of Virginia) to receive affidavits in Isle of Wight, Nansemond, Prince George, and Surry counties, Virginia; and affidavits (copies), 1707, of Robert Bolling, Benjamin Harrison, James Thweatt, and Thomas Wynne.
    Section 16, Various Persons, Affidavits concerning the Boundary between Virginia and North Carolina, 1710-1711
    This section consists of ten items, affidavits, 1710-1711, concerning the boundary between Virginia and North Carolina. Included are affidavits (copies witnessed by Edward Moseley) of William Bonner, George Bullock, William Duckenfield, James Farlee, Lawrence Mague, Richard Sanderson, Edward Smithwick, and Francis Toms; affidavits (copies) of Robert Lawrence and Henry Plumpton; and affidavits (witnessed by Nathaniel Harrison and Philip Ludwell II) of Betty (Indian), Henry Briggs, Great Peter (Indian), Thomas Green (Indian), Nicholas Major (Indian), Mary (Indian), Jenny Pearce (Indian), and the Meherrin and Nottoway Indians.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s